32 Comments
User's avatar
Adam's avatar

FANTASTIC work Packy. I've been subscribed for about 6 weeks now and rarely read the entire piece... but this was just too good.

Keep up the great work.

www.adamtank.com

Expand full comment
Packy McCormick's avatar

Thanks, Adam! I really appreciate that.

Expand full comment
Pierre's avatar

I love that post! Great work!

Expand full comment
Packy McCormick's avatar

thank you, Pierre!

Expand full comment
David Eborall's avatar

Packy, great write-up. You might want to include Prosus in your analysis as another way to buy Tencent at discount. You get their businesses for free with Tencent stake.

Expand full comment
Packy McCormick's avatar

Free businesses on top of free businesses. I like it.

Expand full comment
BK Lee's avatar

Excellent analysis 👏

Expand full comment
Michael's avatar

Worthwhile read, and really great work breaking down such a complexity to a business we can begin to understand. 🙂 Plus have gotten lots of pointers for my startup.

Expand full comment
Ayodeji Tunde-Abatan's avatar

Wow...just wow! Very expository and helpful. Found it on Twitter, now I'm subscribed here too. Keep up your amazing work Packy!

Expand full comment
Elena L's avatar

Great read! Thank you.

Expand full comment
Nicolasz's avatar

Some interesting other tidbits I heard during my time in China.

1. The initial code for their IM copy of ICQ actually contained code from ICQ that was obviously copied.

2. Heard from a friend who worked at Napster that their investment was their “last”investment in China done as they were walking out the door following a few hundred failed investments.

3. Up until round 2010 MaHuateng used to review most launches before they went out the door to make sure they were good for the user.

4. They used to spike revenue numbers for different regions by doing things such as, for a virtual pets product they had, sending a “flu” to all the pets in a region that was missing it numbers that could be only cured by ‘spending” a few rub on a medicine for the pet.

Honestly the most amazing company I’ve seen and am still upset I didn;t keep my ten thousand dollar investment in them in 2006.

Expand full comment
Matthew Myhra's avatar

I've been following Tencent for a few years now and I find it crazy that its not much more widely discussed! This is a very well written break down for many who have little to no knowledge of their success and influence. Good work.

Expand full comment
Forrest Funnell's avatar

Wonderful post!!

Expand full comment
Packy McCormick's avatar

Much appreciated, Forrest!

Expand full comment
Lakshman SAMARANAYAKE's avatar

A brilliant piece of reporting on a company that is absolutely difficult to grasp...congratulations and well done Sir!

Expand full comment
VG's avatar

Brilliant Post Packy. Just a minor correction: The education startup is Byju's and not bydu. btw its the most valuable edtech startup in the world.

Expand full comment
Packy McCormick's avatar

🙈 haha have it in the sheet the right way, but got turned around between Baidu and Bydu in here - will fix!

Expand full comment
Panda Value's avatar

This is a wonderful post - thank you. When looking through your excel file listing out the ownership amounts, many vary from what I have. For instance, you have DOYU at 25%, but it is 38%.

http://ir.huya.com/2020-08-10-Huya-Announces-Receipt-of-Preliminary-Non-Binding-Proposal-from-Tencent

Multiple instances of this: SNAP, SEA, PDD to name a few.

Expand full comment
Packy McCormick's avatar

Thanks for the heads up! Would love to get those updated, would you be able to email or DM me the %'s you have for those?

Expand full comment
Anon's avatar

Thank you for a very helpful post. What is the source for your claim "WeChat users in China spend an average of four hours per day in the app"? Thanks!

Expand full comment
WizardVI's avatar

What a good article!

Expand full comment
Kira Laex's avatar

Packy - amazing work once again! I adore reading your research papers/blogs!

Just a small typo/error you have in the Tencent Portfolio document, I guess an additional zero ended up in the JD.com market cap valuation. :)

All in all, an amazing feeling I can help a bit in the Great Online Game of yours!

Expand full comment