Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ernest Prabhakar's avatar

Dear Not Boring,

Sigh. Deutsch's claim that evil is due to a lack of knowledge may be *literally* true, but it is not *linearly* true. The truth will (eventually) set you free -- but first it really messes you up!

It is easy for us techno-urban elites to decry the petty tribalism of the proletariat. "The future is coming -- you just have to deal with it!"

Which is of course true -- but misleading. The irrational, tradition-bound thinking of our forebears IS what creates a society that enables our comfortable, knowledge-seeking left-brains to ignore petty issues of survival and group identity. Until of course we can't. At which point we close ranks and Other the teeming masses -- just like they (rightfully!) do us.

The hard truth *we* don't want to face is that we actually need them more than they need us. And what we love to style a disinterested pursuit of knowledge (*cough*, elite education) is all too often a status game designed to keep them in their place.

If you really want to model what it feels like to pursue truth at all costs, I dare you to read this Slate Star Codex piece on "tribalism" all the way to the end:

https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/30/i-can-tolerate-anything-except-the-outgroup/

I am an optimist, and I love your optimism. But as you say, the only way we can win is if we have the courage to rightly understand the problem.

Love,

Ernie

Expand full comment
Node Strider's avatar

Just thought I would pop into week 30 to say I love this newsletter and I hope you keep it up.

Can’t wait to read Tim Urban’s new book. Although I’m not sure there’s a viable path away from the tribalism back to truth. Of course objective facts still exist, but everything is so heavily filtered now. The separation between truth and tribal perspective is basically invisible unless you go looking.

A better answer might be new and better (more optimistic) tribes all together.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts