Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Andrew Smith's avatar

I attribute a great deal of my ability to tell a story, along with my ability to make sense of a rapidly changing world, to my early obsession with sci-fi. If you've never done a deep dive into Asimov, Clarke, or any of the old masters, do it now!

Then, steal one of Packy's ideas and write your own sci-fi story. It doesn't need to be amazing.

I did it, and it was really fun!

https://goatfury.substack.com/p/the-founders

Expand full comment
Tara McMullin's avatar

I think this is a very cool project. But it's also easy for science fiction to be reduced to imaginative technology.

Science fiction—and speculative fiction more broadly—is often about wrestling with social and cultural questions in the here and now. Authors tackle these challenging questions by inventing worlds that offer the chance to rethink what's possible. Inventing technology is part of the world invention.

We see over and over again that tech-minded entrepreneurs fixate on devices or new capabilities without wrestling with the social and cultural questions that those ideas were meant to elucidate. Often they take "innovations" that authors meant as cautionary tales and recast them as promising and socially beneficial (Jill Lepore's The Evening Rocket does a good job highlighting this).

Ursula K. Le Guin argues that science fiction is a thought experiment for reconsidering our assumptions and habits—writing that the inventions of the genre are "questions, not answers; process, not stasis."

God knows I love the everyday devices I have that look like something straight off the set of ST:TNG! But it's the social and cultural innovation I value most.

Expand full comment
21 more comments...

No posts